RESEARCH REPORT

In brief

In brief

  • Accenture surveyed 600+ logistics executives and interviewed 14 industry experts to assess the industry’s digital maturity.
  • We found many in the industry struggling to put in the foundations of the digitalization needed to build up resilience against market disruption.
  • A small group of Leaders are investing 2.5x more than Laggards on digitalization – achieving a higher digital maturity than their low-spending peers.
  • ”Efficient Followers” are taking a different route: for half the investment of Leaders, they have gained almost similar levels of digitalization.


Digital state of play

Characterized by low-margin business models, Freight and Logistics companies have traditionally had very limited scope to invest in the digital initiatives advancing other industries. Now, the physical disruptions and economic shocks imposed by the pandemic, and even more recent geo-political impacts, have emphasized the importance for Freight and Logistics players to rapidly accelerate their digital transformation. But not everyone is responding at the same pace or in the same way.

According to global Accenture research, the industry has fragmented digital capabilities. More than three-quarters of our survey participants believe the industry has historically lagged behind in digitalization maturity.

76%

of respondents agree: “Any Freight and Logistics company not focusing on building digital capabilities will seriously endanger their business.”

72%

of respondents agree: “Overall, at an industry level, there is not only an ignorance of digitalization, but also a lack of roadmap in terms of what needs to be done”.

Patchy digitalization progress

The industry is in various stages of building the foundational technologies that will allow companies to respond to market challenges. Based on their digital maturity, measured against 10 digital capabilities grouped into three transformation vectors, we identified:

  • Leaders: These companies, 20% of the entire sample, have developed their position by virtue of a large and growing investment in the percentage of IT spend allocated to innovation – currently 2.5x more than Laggards.
  • Efficient Followers: These businesses, 32% of the entire sample, have managed to achieve similar, if slightly lower, digital maturity levels as Leaders – but for less than half of their percentage of IT spend on innovation.
  • Strivers: Whether for cultural, structural or strategic reasons – the innovation IT spend of Strivers is not fully translating into advanced digital capabilities.
  • Laggards: These companies have the lowest digital capabilities across all metrics and a long way to go to catch up.
Digital maturity of freight and logistics companies

The bubble size represents the number of companies from the sample. The larger bubbles, the more companies in the cluster.

Even the most sophisticated digital leaders have functions or processes that still lag other industries with fully built-out digital capabilities. Many of those further behind have yet to get to grips with the transformation task ahead of them.

Inward-facing digital priorities

Many Freight and Logistics companies may perceive the pace of their digitalization progress as appropriate, but they have only scratched the surface. Research shows they are:

Neglecting the customer front end

80% of respondents characterize investment in customer-facing automation as ‘important’ or ‘very important’. But they also say investment in customer front-end functionality is currently their lowest priority and only a few have fully built out a digitalized customer front end.

Still transitioning to digital processes

75% of respondents still have a large percentage of analog office administration processes, including processing jobs, warehouse operations and accounting. Their plans to automate these processes are focused on the next five years, suggesting a lack of urgency to acquire entry-level digital capabilities.

Struggling to visualize accurate and quality data

Many companies capture sales data, trade lane information, shipment volumes and weights to support internal profitability reporting. But data warehouse capabilities are lacking. Few Freight and Logistics companies are able to capture data from a wide range of sources and use it to inform management decisions.

The Freight and Logistics industry is poised for a radical shake-up as emerging technologies and new business models are harnessed to stabilize global supply chains. But getting to this future will require Freight and Logistics companies to put the foundations of digitalization in place, automating and integrating business and logistics processes and ensuring data accuracy and quality.

Find the right path to digitalization

As the industry works towards digital transformation, we recommend the following steps to get started:

1. Take an honest look at your situation

Use our analysis of clusters and segments to understand where you fit compared with your peers. Be clear on your starting point.

2. Learn from the Leaders and Efficient Followers

Determine where you need to get to by looking at the best in your segment. Where are the sweet spots for quick wins?

3. Create customer-centric investment strategy

Will you invest across the digital spectrum or decide which areas are most important to meet the needs of your customers?

View All

The Freight and Logistics industry needs to find the fastest and most efficient route to digital transformation. This is essential for the continuous adaptation needed to succeed in a future with ever growing customer expectations and where supply chain disruption and volatility have become business as usual.

Christopher Logan

Managing Director – Freight and Logistics Lead, Growth Markets


Mei Yee Pang

Managing Director, Supply Chain Operations Offering Lead – Growth Markets


Ruuchi Chhabra

Senior Manager Freight and Logistics Industry Capability Lead – Global Capability Network

Contributors

Matthias Wahrendorff

Senior Thought Leadership Principal – Accenture Research, Global IIoT and Industrial Research Lead


Michal Hadrys

Research Specialist—Accenture Research Data Science Team

MORE ON THIS TOPIC

Service expansion will decide the winners in logistics
The benefits of supply chain visibility

Subscription Center
Visit our Subscription and Preference Center Visit our Subscription and Preference Center